Welcome to Two Guys Pizza
Two Guys Pizza, located at 3987 Walden Ave in Lancaster, NY, excels in delivering an exceptional pizzeria experience. Renowned for its diverse and innovative menu, the restaurant offers everything from classic pizzas to unique creations like chicken wing pizza and stuffed hot pepper mac n' cheese pizza. Customers rave about the freshness of the ingredients and the generous portion sizes, making every meal a satisfying experience. With a friendly atmosphere and a clean dining area, Two Guys Pizza is praised for its attentive service and the presence of the owner, ensuring high standards. It's a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking quality and creativity.
- 3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086, United States Hotline: +1 716-896-4897
Welcome to the delightful world of Two Guys Pizza, a hidden gem nestled at 3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY. This vibrant eatery has quickly become a local favorite, attracting pizza enthusiasts eager to experience its unique take on traditional favorites. With a phone call away at +1 716-896-4897, you’re just moments from indulging in a flavor-packed adventure.
Two Guys Pizza excels at combining classic pizzeria fare with innovative twists, as highlighted by the diverse menu that offers items like taco pockets, cheeseburger personal pizzas, and even stuffed hot pepper mac n' cheese pizza. Reviewers like TJ have raved about this exciting concoction, calling it one of the most delicious pizzas they’ve ever had. It's this spirit of creativity that sets Two Guys apart in the competitive pizza landscape.
The reviews sing praises not just for the exceptional food, but also for the outstanding service. Customer Kathie Belz appreciates the cleanliness and organization of the kitchen staff, pointing out the value and quality of the food. The warm, welcoming atmosphere here encourages repeat visits, making it a community staple.
What truly stands out are the specialty pizzas, which are available by the slice, allowing patrons to indulge in multiple varieties without the commitment of an entire pie. Steve Gajewski's experience highlights some of these unique options, including chicken wing pizza and big-mac pizza. The ability to sample such inventive flavors is a game changer for pizza lovers.
It's not just about pizza at Two Guys; wings and sides also receive their fair share of attention. Reviewers like Omar Al Yafai agree that the wings are a must-try, alongside crunchy onion rings that complement the meal perfectly. The overall quality of the food is consistently praised, with many customers expressing their intent to return.
Whether you come from near or far, like Ellen Sponholz who hails from Kenmore, you’ll find that the journey to Two Guys Pizza is worth every mile. With a friendly staff and the owner often present to greet customers, the experience is personalized and enjoyable.
If you’re looking for an exceptional pizza experience, filled with unique flavors and a community vibe, Two Guys Pizza is a destination that deserves a spot on your radar. Don’t miss out on this culinary delight; your taste buds will thank you!

My friend gave me a gift card for here. Stating it was very good. So the other night decided to try it. I was very pleased with everything. The service, the food, the value for the amount of food and the organization I witnessed in the kitchen staff. Will definitely be back to try many other items.

This place has amazing food we got taco pockets, cheeseburger personal pizza, & taco logs and nothing was disappointing. This place is a must and a 10/10

Very good food. Their wings are very good and their onion rings are awesome

I came upon this place by accident, and it was great. They had at least four specialty pizzas already made. I chose the Thai Sweet Chili Chicken pizza. I only had two slices, which is rare, but it was filling. I would recommend checking this place out and would stop in again if I were in the area.

Worth the drive from Kenmore to Lancaster! Extensive list of "pizzeria style" menu items as well as some new twists on old favorites. Food is always fresh and well seasoned. Dining area clean and staff is friendly. Owner usually on site as well.

The fact that you can walk in and get 2 slices of unique specialty pizza without ordering a whole pie is great. I've now had the chicken wing pizza, the big-mac pizza, the KFC pizza, and chicken bacon ranch pizza. Every one of them was great!

Your stuffed hot pepper mac n' cheese pizza is the craziest idea and one of the most delicious pizzas I've ever had. Keep up the good work

Every time I drive by I day that I need to stop in but it's always so late in the work day. Today I had time, stopped in and was extremely happy that I finally stopped in. Really great food, big selection of slices ready to eat and wi gs ready to eat as well. Food tasted amazing and the people were really great as well. Will def be stopping in again soon.